Questions to Ask a Roofer Before You Sign Anything

Updated: Oct 30

Most people pick a roofer by price. That makes sense until you realize two quotes for "a new roof" can describe two very different jobs.
One might include new flashing, decking at a set price, and a full tear-off. The other might leave the old flashing, skip the drip edge, and charge whatever they want for rotten wood once your roof is open. The number on the page doesn't tell you which is which. The answers to a few questions do.
Here are the questions we'd want answered if we were hiring a roofer for our own house. Ask them of everyone you talk to, us included.
Questions about the company
"Are you licensed in Tennessee, and what's your license number?"
In Hamilton and Bradley counties, Tennessee requires a Home Improvement license for residential remodeling jobs from $3,000 to under $25,000. At $25,000 and up, a state contractor's license is required in every county. Most roof replacements fall into one of those two ranges, so the roofer should have one or the other. Get the number and look it up on the Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance website before you sign.
"Can your insurance agent send me a certificate of insurance?"
You want proof of general liability and workers' compensation coverage, sent straight from their insurance agent, not a photocopy they hand you. Liability covers damage to your house. Workers' comp covers a worker who gets hurt on your roof. Without it, you don't want to find out who pays.
3. "Who will actually be on my roof?"
Some companies use their own crew. Others sell the job and hand it to a subcontractor. Neither is automatically bad, but you should know which it is, and who's in charge on site if something goes wrong.
"Where are you based, and how long have you been in business?"
A local address and a track record mean they'll be around if something needs fixing later. Ask for a few customers nearby you can call, and read their reviews.
Questions about the inspection and the quote
"Did you get on the roof, and can I see photos?"
A quote written from the driveway is a guess. You should see photos of what they found, especially anything they say needs replacing.
"How many layers are on the roof now?"
If there's already a second layer, everything has to come off down to the deck. That changes the price, and an honest quote accounts for it up front.
"What happens if you find bad decking, and what does it cost?"
Nobody can see the decking until the old roof comes off. The quote should say what replacement decking costs per sheet, in writing, so the price can't jump once your roof is open.
"What exactly is included?"
Ask the roofer to walk you through the line items. A complete replacement quote should cover:
Tear-off and disposal of the old roof
The shingle brand and product line
Underlayment, and ice and water barrier in valleys and other leak-prone areas
New flashing at chimneys, walls, and valleys, not just resealing the old
Drip edge, pipe boots, and vents
Ridge caps
Cleanup, including a sweep for nails
If two quotes are far apart, this list is usually where the difference hides.
Questions about the job itself
"Does this job need a permit, and who pulls it?"
Rules vary by city and county. The roofer should know what yours requires and handle it, not leave it to you.
"When can you start, and how long will it take?"
You want a realistic start window and a realistic length, not the shortest number that wins the job. Ask what happens if they get pulled onto a bigger job halfway through yours.
"What happens if it rains with my roof open?"
The answer should be specific: how they watch the weather, how much they tear off at once, and how they cover it if a storm rolls in.
"How do you protect the house and yard?"
Ask about landscaping, windows, the AC unit, and where the dumpster or trailer will sit. Ask how they clean up nails, and whether they'll do a final walk with you.
"Who do I call during the job?"
You want one name and one number for someone who can actually answer questions, not a general office line.
Questions about money
"How much do you need up front, and when is the rest due?"
Payment terms vary a lot between roofers. Some ask for a deposit, some ask for nothing until the job is done. Whatever the terms are, they should be in writing before work starts. Be careful with large up-front payments, especially to someone you found the same week.
"What could change the price after I sign?"
The honest answer is usually short: bad decking at the per-sheet price, or something hidden that nobody could see. Ask how they'll tell you before doing extra work, and get that in writing too.
"If insurance is paying, what will the contract include?"
Tennessee has a specific rule for roofers paid through insurance. The contract has to give you the right to cancel within three days, list the roofer's address, phone number, license number, and email, and describe the repairs in detail. If a storm-damage contract is missing those, that's a problem.
And remember who decides what's covered: your insurance company. A roofer can document damage, but no roofer can promise what your claim will pay.
Questions about warranties
There are two kinds of roof warranty, and most people only hear about one.
The manufacturer warrantyĀ comes from the shingle company and covers defects in the materials.
The workmanship warrantyĀ comes from the roofer and covers mistakes in the installation. Most roof problems in the first few years are installation problems, so this one matters.
"What does your workmanship warranty cover, and for how long?"
Get it in writing. Ask what's excluded and what you'd have to do to make a claim. A long warranty is only as good as the company behind it, which is one more reason to hire someone local with a track record.
"Which manufacturer warranty will I get, and do you register it?"
The stronger manufacturer warranties often require a certified installer and registration after the job. Ask who handles the registration and when you'll get the paperwork.
"Does the warranty transfer if I sell the house?"
Some do, some don't, and some have conditions. If you might sell in the next ten years, it's worth knowing.
Red flags that should end the conversation
They knock on your door right after a storm and want to sign you today.
They won't give you a license number or proof of insurance.
The quote is one line: "new roof, $X."
They never got on the roof or into the attic.
They want most of the money up front, or cash only.
They promise insurance will pay for everything.
They push back when you say you want another quote.
A good roofer expects these questions. If someone gets annoyed when you ask them, that tells you what working with them will be like.
The checklist
Print this, and bring it to every roofer you talk to.
Tennessee license number, looked up and active
Certificate of insurance sent from their agent, with liability and workers' comp
I know who will be on my roof and who's in charge
I've seen photos of my roof from the inspection
I know how many layers are on the roof
Decking price per sheet is in writing
The quote lists materials, flashing, drip edge, vents, and cleanup
I know whether a permit is needed and who pulls it
Start date, timeline, and rain plan are clear
Payment terms are in writing
Workmanship and manufacturer warranties are explained in writing
Ask us, too
We're Josiah and Sam, two brothers who run Riverbend Roofing out of East Brainerd. Bring this list when you call. We'll get up on your roof, send you photos and video of what we find, and answer every question on it. If it's a repair, we'll tell you that. On most jobs, you don't pay us anything until the work is finished and you've looked at it.
Call 423-718-0594 or request a free inspection. We work across Chattanooga, Hixson, Red Bank, Ooltewah, Soddy-Daisy, and Cleveland.
Sources
Tennessee Board for Licensing Contractors, Home Improvement: Home Improvement license for $3,000 to under $25,000 in Hamilton, Bradley, and seven other counties, and the insurance-paid roofing contract rule (Public Chapter 821, effective July 1, 2012).
Tennessee Board for Licensing Contractors, consumer rights sheet: state contractor's license required at $25,000 and up in every county.




Comments