4 Decisions You'll Have to Make When Replacing Your Roof


Most people replace a roof once, maybe twice, in their lives. So when it's time, there's no muscle memory. You're suddenly making choices you've never had to think about, often with a roofer waiting for an answer.
It gets easier once you know what's coming. Almost every roof replacement comes down to the same four decisions. Here they are, in the order you'll usually face them, with what to think about for each.
Decision 1: Who you hire
This is the decision that shapes all the others. The roofer you pick will measure the roof, tell you what's wrong with it, recommend the material, and install every part you'll never see. A great shingle installed badly is a bad roof.
What to look for:
A Tennessee license you've looked up. Check it at verify.tn.gov.
Proof of insurance sent from their agent: general liability and workers' comp.
A local address and a track record, so they'll be around if something needs fixing.
An inspection with photos, not a quote written from the driveway.
A detailed written quote that lists the tear-off, the decking price per sheet, the shingle by name, and every part of the roof system.
A written workmanship warranty.
Get more than one quote, and compare them line by line, not just by the total. Our questions to ask a roofer article has the full checklist.
Decision 2: What goes on the roof
The material. For most houses around Chattanooga, this is a choice between kinds of asphalt shingles. InterNACHI, the home inspectors' association, estimates about 20 years for 3-tab shingles and about 30 for architectural shingles, which are thicker and layered. Metal, slate, and tile last much longer but cost much more, and slate and tile are heavy enough that not every house can carry them.
The product line. Within each shingle type, manufacturers offer good, better, and best lines. Higher lines usually mean a heavier shingle, better wind ratings, and stronger warranty options. Ask your roofer to name the exact product they're quoting, so you can compare apples to apples.
The rest of the system. Shingles are only the part you see. Ask about:
Underlayment over the whole deck, and ice and water barrier in the valleys and other leak-prone spots
New flashing, drip edge, and pipe boots
Starter strips and ridge caps, ideally from the same manufacturer as the shingles, since some warranties require it
Ventilation: whether your attic has enough intake at the eaves and exhaust at the ridge
These choices matter as much as the shingle you pick.
Decision 3: What color
It sounds like the easy one, but you'll look at this color for the next 20 or 30 years, and so will anyone who might buy your house.
Things to weigh:
Your HOA. If you have one, check its rules first. Some limit shingle colors or styles, and getting it wrong can mean a letter, or redoing the work.
The rest of the house. Pick a color that works with your brick or siding, trim, and shutters, not one that fights them.
The neighborhood. A roof that fits the street usually helps resale more than one that stands out.
Heat. Lighter colors reflect more sunlight than darker ones. Attic ventilation matters too, so don't pick a color for heat alone.
How it looks in person. A shingle on a small sample board or a screen can look very different across a whole roof in full sun. Ask your roofer for a full-size sample, or for addresses of houses with that color you can drive by.
Decision 4: How and when you'll pay for it
How you'll pay. Most homeowners use one of these, or a mix:
Savings, ideally set aside once the roof passes its halfway point.
Insurance, if a storm caused the damage. Your insurer decides what's covered, and you'll still pay your deductible. Our storm damage and insurance article walks through the claim.
Financing, through the roofer or a lender. Compare the interest rate and total cost, not just the monthly payment.
If you decide to go with us, we do offer financing through Acorn Financing!
What you'll pay, and when. Get the payment schedule in writing before work starts. In Tennessee, home improvement law prohibits contractors from asking for a down payment of more than one-third of the total contract, and the state advises never paying the full amount before the work is done.
When to do it. Don't wait for a leak if the roof is clearly near the end. A replacement you plan for gives you time to compare quotes and pick a date, instead of taking whoever can come fastest. Roofers here work most of the year, but busy seasons, especially right after big storms, can mean longer waits, so call early.
Your four decisions at a glance
Roofer: licensed, insured, local, with a detailed written quote and warranty
Material: shingle type and exact product line, plus the full roof system and ventilation
Color: checked against your HOA, your house, and a full-size sample
Payment: how you'll pay, the schedule in writing, and a date that works for you
We'll help you with all four
We're Josiah and Sam, two brothers who run Riverbend Roofing out of East Brainerd. We'll get up on your roof, send you photos and video of what we find, and walk you through each of these decisions, with the shingle, color, and price spelled out in writing. If it's a repair, we'll tell you that. On most jobs, you don't pay us anything until the work is finished and you've looked at it.
Call 423-718-0594 or request a free inspection. We work across Chattanooga, Hixson, Red Bank, Ooltewah, Soddy-Daisy, and Cleveland.
Sources
InterNACHI Standard Estimated Life Expectancy Chart for Homes: 3-tab about 20 years, architectural about 30.
Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance, storm tips: verify.tn.gov, the one-third down payment limit, and not paying in full before the work is done.
GAF Shingle & Accessory Limited Warranty: example of matching accessories affecting warranty coverage (higher wind coverage requires the manufacturer's starter strips).




Comments